With all due respect to Drs Seddon and Sunderland, reconciling
electrophysiologic data with surgical and anatomic models is
problematic.** We seldom are dealing with open traumatic wounds or nerves
that are pinched with a watchmaker’s forceps. All completely severed
nerves will produce unevokable (no response) motor and sensory action
potentials with NCS. However, not every “no response” observed means that
the nerve has been severed. In some instances (radial neuropathy-spiral
groove with mid humeral fracture), recovery is predictable and orderly. In
other instances, unevokable responses (severe carpal tunnel syndrome) need
surgical intervention.
In addition, the models described by Seddon and Sunderland do not
address varying degrees of pathology noted involving sensory and motor
fibers. In general, (carpal tunnel syndrome), mild/early pathology seems
to affect sensory NCS before motor changes.
In general, depending on the nerve, degree of pathology identified via
EMG/NCS escalates from sensory to motor NCS change, to EMG changes. A
sensory response will usually become unevokable in the presence of a still
involved, but evokable motor response. Abnormal motor and sensory NCS can
describe pathology in the presence of a normal EMG.
When describing a nerve injury an attempt should be made to identify
the degree of sensory NCS, motor NCS and EMG changes noted. At that point,
treatment is predicated on historic knowledge of how other similar cases
have responded. Mid humeral fracture with radial neuropathy usually
respond, even though the nerve appears “neurotmetic” distal to the triceps
brachii. Median neuropathy at the wrist with unevokable motor/sensory
responses and complete thenar denervation may improve in a fourteen year
old suffering a distal radius fracture. The same data in 55-year-old woman
may be an indication for surgery.
**Dr. Jun Kimura has attempted to utilize terms described by Seddon
based on the chronology of nerve degeneration following an injury. He
describes NCS within the first four days following a nerve injury. NCS
results in an unevokable response with stimulation proximal to the lesion
site. At that point in time, it is not known if the terms neuropraxia,
axonotmesis, or neurotmesis may be used.
If a nerve has been severed, the nerve segment distal to the lesion
remains electrically viable for the first 4-7 days. Evaluation of that
segment will remain normal during that period of time, even though the
nerve is severed. During the 2nd week, if responses are unevokable, the
term neurotmesis may be invoked. Axonotmesis will produce a reduced
response, neuropraxia normal response.